Monica

So I can’t really rate Nym accurately. The game has been rough from the start. Cancellations, both from the DM and from too many party members unavailable plagued the campaign. But I can say that I was disappointed in what we did get to play. I deeply developed a pretty in depth backstory that was never mentioned nor touched on. Nym gave us options for character development: a magic item, Ability Scores, or dark bargain. I chose dark bargain - symbiote. Nym never worked with me on symbiote development. The symbiote was never mentioned nor touched upon, nor used. My character was instantly killed in the Black Cabin and never brought back to life so she remained a ghost for the rest of that session and then Nym just cancelled the campaign, I’m sure out of frustration about cancellations by party members but geesh, that was just unexpected and out of no where. I can’t recommend Nym to my friends. Sorry Nym.

Isaac was very patient either me as someone who had never heard of Legends In The Mist or tag based gaming. He was a great teacher. And he played rule of cool, as we described an action or actions and he weighed which tags would fit within the scenario presented. I had a great time at his table and will def play again in the future! UPDATE: Playing Crooked Moon with Isaac. The music is terrific, adding to the atmosphere. And the descriptions are brilliant. I also like the way he asks how my character feels, thinks, or behaves when he is doing a thing, though it does put me on the spot. I would def recommend Isaac.

I am the only one in the group that hadn’t seen or known Sui prior to joining the campaign. It is quite a honour to be at his table. He is creative and highly imaginative. I like his custom hit dice rules and how he plays with rules for fun throughout. If we think up something creative, he lets us try it.

🌟 Five Stars – A Fantastic First-Time DM! Isaac’s first campaign, Living Up to the Legend, is already something special. His world is rich with detail, full of interconnected characters and stories that make every choice feel meaningful. He’s confident with the rules, generous with roleplay, and encourages exploration and creativity. As a new bard player, I’ve felt completely supported—Isaac is patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares about each player’s experience. A phenomenal start to what I know will be a legendary DM journey! UPDATE: Isaac is a masterful DM who guided the flow and direction of this short (6 week) campaign to an uber epic ending that was suspected would be the outcome but was filled with twists and turns that left the epilogue extremely fulfilling, though there was a tragic end. Everyone needs to step into Brescia and explore this homebrew created masterfully by this GM!

I love playing at Joel’s tables. He really knows how to set a tone and atmosphere. He also is really patient with us and helps us walk through the mechanics of VTT gaming. And the story is role play driven through the campaign story arc.