Michael

Had a great time with him as DM and the group we had at the table. Sadly had to leave early cause of RL.

While all the bells and whistles are nice, but they don't cover the fact that a DM with all this experience didn't even know how light weapon property in 5.5 works. He uses a lot of AI and only plays the same module over and over. That fine but honestly it's not as creative as you expect from some one with 45+ experience. By the way the red box set didn't come out in 1978, it came out in 1983. You prob mean the basic box set that came out in 1977. I normally don't do bad reviews but this just left a sour feeling after the session. Maybe other players will have better games and fun, but I sure as hell didn't. And I wasn't the only one to leave. Another player left mid session. So that tells you something not working out.

Had a great time and Mallow keep the story engaging and fun. Would for sure play with him again.

Had a great time with the group even though I came in late. Though plan to continue on with next adventure with new chars. Tyler is very engaging and makes the RP and fights fun.

Played ToA with Spider and loved the game and his style. While it was deadly but it was also fun. Sadly the game had to end when we lost to many players. Though I for sure will join another game he's running. He keep the sessions flow and a good mixture of RP and Combat.