Mark

He writes good stories, makes good maps, and portrays action and NPCs well. He is less good at balancing the game, and his approach to players' characters borders on being antagonistic. After he complained following a 3+ hour combat that PCs weren't hurt enough, he told all of the players to remove all 2024 spells and abilities that he had approved for their characters sessions before. Attempting to balance things through a large-scale overreaction is a sign of inexperience, and while that's alright for a casual game, it's not cool when you're presenting yourself as a professional and being paid.

The two one-shots I have played with Ryley are among the best I've played with any DM. They are quick on their feet, and they have a firm grasp of how rules and story support each other. Ryley voices each NPC distinctly and clearly, and they move back and forth seamlessly between the VTT (Owlbear Rodeo) and theater of the mind. Finally, you can tell how good a DM is by the quality of the players they attract, and Ryley has drawn together a fun, friendly, creative, and skilled group of collaborative players.

I've both played with Mel as a player and played in the Wild Beyond Witchlight game they DM, and it's always lots of fun.

The DM is a pleasant guy. He did a good job of describing the setting and action, and he voiced the NPCs really well.

Arden was consistently friendly and upbeat. The level 20, "anything goes" on-shot that he ran led to some fairly wild shenanigans and, in one instance, potential PvP and (maybe inadvertent) rule-breaking by one particular player, but he kept things moving regardless. The game itself felt rough around the edges; we effectively were just plopped onto the battle map and told to roll initiative. However, Arden definitely worked to keep things fun for everyone, and he was great to interact with, both in the game and on his Discord beforehand. I definitely would play with him again.