Travis

Matt runs the best table I've played at. He's prepared, organized, and completely present for the whole session. Our Frostmaiden campaign could easily drag, but he keeps the dread doing real work while the story moves, and our choices actually change where it goes. Long sessions never feel long. He builds characters with you. I wanted my warlock's patron to be a Loki-style trickster inspired by Kobold Press material. Matt didn't just allow it, he wove it into the story at level 3 so it became part of the campaign, not a note on my sheet. Sessions start on time, rulings are quick and fair, and every player gets their moment. He runs everything through Threadfall, so we get a full written recap and a living codex of every NPC and place after each session. Discord play is seamless. Whatever Matt runs next, book it.

Andy is a phenomenal GM — creative, patient, and genuinely collaborative. He strikes the perfect balance between running a structured story and adapting to the players’ ideas in real time. When one of our players had to leave the campaign between sessions, Andy didn’t just erase the character — he worked with us to turn it into a meaningful story moment, letting the NPC finish our escape attempt naturally instead of retconning it away. He’s open to feedback, quick to incorporate character-driven ideas, and brings the Underdark to life in a way that feels cinematic and personal. Whether you’re brand new or seasoned, Andy makes every player feel essential to the story.