Amber

Shatargat is a great DM. I'm in A Time to Harvest, which is a Call of Cthulhu game, and he excels in setting the mood. He definitely makes it feel creepy and puts a lot of fun tension into the session. The adventure also hosts a large number of NPCs and he's very good at playing them and making each one distinct and memorable.

Had a great time in Strifey's game. He's great at setting up the mood and atmosphere and really makes the game genuinely creepy.

Aaron is a very friendly, competent GM who is a lot of fun to play with. This was my first game with StartPlaying and it's been a very positive experience.