Al

He can DM well and give good life to the game and characters. My main problem was with his communication and some unethical practices. He purposefully creates multiple listings and then cancels one of his groups fills. I feel that this is rather unethical and unprofessional and even perhaps against TOS in SPG. Finally, he failed to communicate that he would be running PCs when they are away, and afterwards, just acted like there was a lack of communication. I would recommend if you don't mind the headaches and unethical stuff.

Good things: He engages with his players and runs standard module games. He knows his rules. Bad things: He lacks energy, and the game felt flat as a result. Also, he is a bit too controlling where I had to share screens while making a character because he had bad experiences some players. This was pretty much in session 0 when I made my character with him, and it really set a bad tone of someone who would rather get things perfect rather than working off of implicit trust, especially in the beginning