Andrew - The Real MacGuffin

he/him

5.0

(19)

Timezone

America/new York

Language

English

Identity

Streamer

Podcaster

BIMPOC

Asian

About Andrew - The Real MacGuffin

Hi, I’m Andrew - let’s tell a great story together. I’m a lifelong storyteller and professional Game Master with 30+ years behind the screen. I cut my teeth on Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, but over the years I’ve fallen deeply in love with narrative-first, rules-light(ish) games - the kind that put character, emotion, and collaboration at the heart of play. I’m also a core member of the Looking for Mom YouTube channel, a popular and growing actual-play community where I regularly live stream games like Daggerheart, Outgunned, and many other TTRPGs. Running games for a live audience has sharpened my pacing, improvisation, and ability to spotlight players - skills I bring to every table, streamed or not. If you’re looking for a table where your character matters, where choices have weight, and where the story belongs to all of us - not just the GM - you’re in the right place. Why Join My Table? 🎭 Immersive, Character-Driven Storytelling I build vivid worlds filled with tension, wonder, and humanity - but your characters are always the stars. I treat every game like a shared writers’ room, where player choices actively shape the world, the themes, and the outcome. ✨ Character-Driven Stories I favor systems that get out of the way and let the story breathe. Expect: - Meaningful character moments - Improvisation and creative problem-solving - Drama that emerges naturally from play - not from rigid rules - Combat, when it happens, is dynamic and consequential - but never the only way forward. 🌈 A Welcoming, Inclusive Table My tables are safe, respectful, and affirming. New players, veteran role-players, and everyone in between are welcome. I take safety tools seriously, communicate expectations clearly, and prioritize player comfort - so everyone can fully invest in the story. Games I Love to Run - Daggerheart - Outgunned - Vaesen - The Electric State - Blade Runner RPG (And I’m always happy to talk about custom campaigns or one-shots!) What Players Are Saying: 🌟 "He is committed to his craft and will spoil you with that extra polish and knack for immersive storytelling." 🌟 "Andrew really sets the standard GMing for veteran, returning or new players." 🌟 "Andrew was able to help me feel comfortable and made me feel like I was the greatest player" Let’s Play Whether this is your first session or your hundredth, I believe there’s always room for a great story—and a seat for you at my table. Have questions? Curious if a game is the right fit? Reach out anytime—I’m always happy to chat. Let’s create something unforgettable.

At a glance

4 years on StartPlaying

27 games hosted

Highly rated for: Creativity, Storytelling, Inclusive

Featured Prompts

My favorite system of all Time is

Daggerheart and Outgunned!

How Andrew - The Real MacGuffin runs games

Your character matters. The heroes you bring to the table aren’t passengers in the story - they’re its beating heart. I take the time to weave personal arcs shaped by your goals, flaws, histories, and hard choices, and those arcs meaningfully influence the world around you. Roleplay comes first. Your decisions - who you trust, what you risk, when you hesitate - send ripples through the narrative. Triumphs feel earned, mistakes matter, and consequences make the story richer. That sense of cause and effect is where the magic lives. Combat has weight. No filler fights or mindless skirmishes. When blades are drawn, it matters. Expect tension, strategy, real stakes, and the occasional breath-held moment where everything hangs in the balance. Every session is crafted with intention. Whether we’re exploring a published module or one of my custom-built worlds, I love introducing fresh twists and unexpected elements that keep even veteran players surprised and engaged. Above all, this is a welcoming table. I strive to create a space where you feel respected, supported, and free to take creative risks. We’ll tell powerful stories, share plenty of laughs, and walk away with moments that linger long after the final roll. Let’s make something memorable - together!

Andrew - The Real MacGuffin's ideal table

My table is collaborative, character-focused, and story-driven. The players who thrive here are the ones who enjoy engaging with the world, the NPCs, and each other - not just reacting to events, but actively helping to shape where the story goes. If you like leaning into roleplay, building relationships, making meaningful choices, and embracing the unexpected, you’ll feel right at home. Who Fits Well at My Table - Players who enjoy collaborative storytelling and a “Yes, and…” mindset - Roleplayers who like exploring character motivations, flaws, and growth - Creative problem-solvers who see the world as something to interact with, not just overcome - Players who respect spotlight sharing and enjoy elevating others at the table - New players excited to learn in a supportive environment, and veterans eager to dig deeper The Vibe The overall vibe is immersive, thoughtful, and warm, with plenty of room for humor and levity. We take the story seriously - but not ourselves. Expect moments of tension and emotion balanced by laughter, camaraderie, and shared excitement when things go sideways in the best possible way. I encourage: - Talking in character when it feels right - Building off each other’s ideas - Taking creative risks, even if they don’t always work out Table Expectations This is a respectful, inclusive space. Everyone is expected to: - Be kind and welcoming - Listen as much as they speak - Support each other’s fun, even when characters disagree Rules exist to support the story, not to get in its way, and I’ll always prioritize player comfort and clarity at the table. If you’re looking for a game where everyone contributes, the story evolves organically, and your character is treated as an essential part of the world - not just a stat block - then my table is likely a great fit. Come curious. Come collaborative. Let’s tell something amazing together!